Someday, burning optical media like CDs and DVDs may be a fully supported operating system feature. Until then, Windows users have to use burning software packages that unfortunately tend to bundle complexity and cost with a lot of frustration. Windows XP does support minimal burn operations when blank CDs and DVDs are opened as “writable” windows in My Computer, but this is not enough for creating anything beyond basic data disks.
I have used commercial burn software packages (like Nero and Roxio) before, but I chose not to use these packages again for a few recent projects. Here’s why:
- For a home user who rarely (read, almost never) needs to burn media anyway, it is difficult to justify the cost of either package.
- Both Nero and Roxio bundle a lot of useless junkware into their packages (perhaps partially to justify their pricetag) and all I need is basic burn functionality.
- Removing remnants of an expired “trial” version of either is not a task I relish. I’ve found (and Wikipedia concurs) that even licensed copies of these programs are hard to remove.
With this in mind, I set out to find open source or freeware burn software without needless frills. I was looking for actively developed projects which might continue to be useful in the future. Two programs which do just that are InfraRecorder and ImgBurn.
InfraRecorder is an open-source project, and it supports creating various data and audio CDs and DVDs (at this writing, it is in version 0.45). It does not yet support the creation of video DVDs, but it has a fairly simple interface, and enough basic documentation to help most users. I used it to burn a a large collection of MP3 files to a DVD without any problems.
ImgBurn is freeware, and supports data, audio, and video for CDs, DVDs, HD-DVDs, and Blu-ray (at this writing, it is in version 2.4.2.0). The interface is very clean and operation is straightforward. I probably like this program better than InfraRecorder because its basic approach appeals to me.
Rather than modeling all its operations like other burning software which combine high-level tasks like “Copy disk” or “Burn data disk” with lower-level processes such as creating a disk image, ImgBurn does everything from a low-level perspective. If you want to copy a disk, you first run the process to create an image file of the original disk, and then you insert a blank disk and burn the image file into the new disk. Although this approach may seem more technical to a new user than a higher-level approach, this approach is so simple (and the tutorials so straightforward) that when I first used it I feared that I was missing some detail simply because it seemed too easy to be true.
Amazingly, with all this simplicity, it really does support a high degree of customization for advanced users. The complexity is accessible, but you don’t have to deal with it unless you seek it out.
I’m glad I finally put some effort into finding burn software for future projects. Both of these are good programs that don’t annoy me in any of the ways the commercial packages did, and hopefully they’ll still be useful as technology and media standards progress. At least for now, these two will probably remain my burn packages of choice.
Recent Comments